FMC urges finance ministry to reduce commodity transaction tax

The Forward Markets Commission(FMC) urged the finance ministry to remove or reduce the commodity transaction tax (CTT) in the forthcoming budget because it has severely hit trade volume in the decade-old commodity futures market.

Brokers said the tax of 0.01% on the seller along with lack of volatility has hit futures volume by 40% since it was imposed in July 2013. FMC data show that volume shrank 41% to Rs 101.4 lakh crore in FY14, the fiscal year the tax was introduced on non-farm and processed farm contracts such as gold, silver, crude oil, cotton, soya oil and sugar.

In the fiscal year through January 2015, volume has fallen 42% to Rs 51.3 lakh crore from the same period last year. Moreover, commodity transaction tax collection has been significantly lower than that from securities transaction tax (STT) on stock market transactions.

On MCX, the country's largest commodity exchange with 90% market share, collection in the fiscal year through December was Rs 374.35 crore against Rs 4,940 crore in securities transaction tax over the same period.

"There has been a recommendation to remove or reduce the tax," said a government official. "Introduction of commodity transaction tax has drastically affected volumes and since the commodity futures market is nascent, it's imperative to either wholly remove the tax or to reduce it substantially," said Suresh Nair, director, Admisi Commodities.

The previous UPA government, which introduced the tax at a rate of Rs 10 per Rs 1 lakh on the sell side, justified it on the ground that a huge number of transactions on the commodity futures market did not result in delivery. Officials from leading exchanges such as MCX and NCDEX - specialising in farm and non-farm contracts respectively - argued that physical market constituents used the market to hedge their price risk and not necessarily to give or take delivery.

Further, they pointed out that speculators provided the market with liquidity by taking a contrarian position to that of hedgers. Some of these market participants, who squared off their positions on a daily basis, would be forced out of the market because of commodity transaction tax as the narrow spreads they trade on are being squeezed by the tax.

In the current fiscal year through January, bullion (gold and silver) volumes are down 53% to Rs 18.3 lakh crore, energy by 39% to Rs 13.1 lakh crore and base metals by 32% to Rs 10.6 lakh crore. Bullion accounted for 70% of the overall turnover, followed by energy (26%) and base metals (21%).